Victims of drunk drivers need protection! Drunk drivers case many fatal accidents and serious injuries in North Carolina. Our firm ONLY handles motor vehicle accident cases, and our focus is on serious collisions and significant injuries. Carl Nagle is a former claims adjuster and former insurance company lawyer, and we also have two retired NC State Troopers who work with our firm to investigate crashes, follow drunk driving criminal charges, and pursue maximum payment for injury claims and punitive damages when drunk drivers injure our clients.
We have had multiple high-value cases involving drunk drivers. We have collected punitive damages to punish highly intoxicated drivers. Our sole focus on crash-related injury cases gives us the medical and law-enforcement experience needed to prove your injury case and to investigate the collision and hold the drunk driver accountable. We also offer the lowest legal fee of all North Carolina injury law firms. Our fee is 25% of settlement, while other firms charge 33.3%. We are here now to protect and enforce your legal rights.
You drive responsibly and follow the rules of the road to protect your fellow motorists. But are other drivers doing the same to protect you?
According to the CDC, over 10,000 people lose their lives on American highways and roads due to alcohol-related accidents every year. That averages out to 29 fatalities each day, or roughly one every 50 minutes. In North Carolina, about one-third of all traffic deaths are associated with alcohol-impaired drivers. While DUI injuries and fatalities are declining, causing one injury or killing one person due to negligence is one too many.
Most people understand that it's wrong to drive after drinking - even after one or two drinks. Despite that knowledge, thousands of otherwise responsible motorists have no problem cranking their cars and driving home after drinking. While they may not intend to hurt anyone, this dangerous choice leads to countless injuries and fatalities each year, profoundly affecting the lives of both the victims and the intoxicated drivers, as well as their families.
At Nagle and Associates, we're dedicated to holding drunk drivers accountable for their actions and the pain and suffering they cause their victims. Our drunk driving accident attorneys in Charlotte, NC focus solely on representing those injured in such accidents - not those who choose to drive while drunk.
It doesn't take a graduate from University of North Carolina at Charlotte near Charlotte, NC to know that DUI accidents are both frightening and damaging. One minute, you're driving home from work, thinking about what you and your family will have for dinner. Then, out of nowhere, an intoxicated driver sideswipes you on the highway, forcing you out of control into a ditch. Your car is totaled, your body hurts, and now, your life is forever changed.
If you or a loved one has been involved in an alcohol-related traffic accident, we're here to help. We recognize that this is an incredibly stressful time—one where you'd rather focus on your health and family's peace of mind instead of handling court paperwork, gathering witness statements, and dealing with police, insurance adjusters, insurance lawyers and judges. That's exactly where our extensive experience pursuing drunk drivers comes into play. We've represented DUI victims in a number of different cases, some of which involve:
Our experienced DUI litigators have the knowledge and connections to secure the financial compensation you need for all past and future medical bills and lost wages. We also know how to investigate the collision, assemble your medical evidence, validate your threat of litigation, and compel the insurance companies to pay the highest tax-free settlement for your injury claims. When you work with a drunk driving accident attorney in Charlotte, NC from Nagle & Associates, you have the best shot at securing a generous lump-sum payment for your financial losses, and for your pain, suffering, and diminished quality of life.
Simply put, Carl Nagle and our team of trial lawyers focus exclusively on roadway cases like DUI/DWI accidents. We've obtained millions of dollars for victims just like you, who are forced to suffer due to someone else's extremely dangerous and careless actions. Like Historic Rosedale in Charlotte, NC, you can count on us to be there and stand strong when you need us most. Insurance companies cannot dissuade us, and their adjusters and lawyers will not diminish your legal rights!
Additional reasons to consider our drunk driving accident law firm include:
Wondering whether you qualify for financial help after being hit by a drunk driver? Contact Nagle & Associates today so that we can strategize on how to proceed with your case. Your first consultation is always free.
Here's a sad fact that may open your eyes: The Tar Heel State has some of the highest rates of DUI accidents in the entire country. According to data provided by the North Carolina DMV, over 11,000 people were arrested for DUI in 2019 alone. Tragically, in the same year, 348 people were killed in drunk driving accidents. 75% of the drivers in those fatal crashes had been charged with DUI before. To help prevent and reduce car wrecks caused by impaired drivers, North Carolina implements strict drunk driving penalties and laws.
In North Carolina, the law establishes that a driver is considered impaired if they are at least 21 years old and have a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) exceeding .08. For those operating commercial vehicles, like taxicabs or trucks, the legal BAC limit is lowered to .04. Additionally, there is a strict zero-tolerance policy for drivers under the age of 21. It's also illegal under North Carolina law to drive with any detectable amount of a Schedule I controlled substance in your bloodstream.
Another aspect of law to consider is the North Carolina Exemplary Damages Act. This law permits victims of "willful and wanton conduct" to seek extra financial damages, commonly referred to as punitive damages. However, the laws surrounding punitive damages in North Carolina are fairly restrictive, with many judges looking for multiple DWI offenses before allowing such claims. As a result, your drunk driving accident lawyer from Nagle & Associates will examine the criminal history of impaired drivers along with other wrongful actions to strengthen our case for additional punitive damages.
In short, yes, having a seasoned North Carolina drunk driving accident injury lawyer by your side helps your case immensely. At Nagle & Associates, we're passionate about protecting your rights and take every step necessary to enforce those rights and pursue maximum payment from the drunk driver, their insurance carrier and any other parties who share liability for your injuries and damages:
If you've been involved in an accident, you might be recovering from your injuries in Charter Senior Living of Charlotte in Charlotte, NC, dealing with lost wages, overwhelming medical bills, vehicle repair costs, out-of-pocket expenses, and a complex maze of insurance claims. During this challenging time, it's reassuring to know that someone is dedicated to fighting for your rights and seeking the justice you deserve.
When you're involved in a drunk driving accident, there's a good chance you'll get a phone call from an insurance adjuster very soon after the accident. Carl Nagle is a former adjuster, and he cautions you that "insurance adjusters are trained to be diplomatic, to earn your trust so you will cooperate with their efforts to underpay your claims". The friendly adjuster is the most dangerous adjuster - they are being paid to oppose your claims, yet they are willing to appear to be friendly and helpful when you are dealing with serious injuries and frightening financial circumstances. Please remember, North Carolina insurance adjusters who handle your claims against the drunk driver who caused your accident have one goal: to minimize the amount of money the insurance company must pay you.
Making a statement or accepting an early settlement offer without first talking to a drunk driving accident attorney in Charlotte, NC can lead to significant consequences and a loss of valuable legal rights. Insurance adjusters are skilled at eliciting statements or admissions of guilt that can be used to diminish the value of your claim. That's why it's so important to consult with an attorney before interacting with any insurance claims adjuster. You should also be wary of insurance adjusters because North Carolina follows the Pure Contributory Negligence rule. If an insurance adjuster can claim that you played a role in causing the accident or your injuries, they might attempt to deny your claim entirely.
Fortunately, our strict negligence law does have an exception that applies in cases caused by drunk drivers. In a typical crash case, if you are slightly at fault for the accident, you have no right to present claims or collect for car damage or injury claims. If you are just 1% at fault, you get nothing for your accident claims. However, if a drunk driver is guilty of "gross negligence", the Pure Contributory Negligence rule does not apply. Our legal team can help you win if the insurance company tries to blame you for an accident involving a drunk driver.
We strongly recommend speaking with a DUI accident lawyer before you being cooperating and working with any insurance adjusters or claims representatives. Nagle & Associates' attorneys can guide you through the legal intricacies of filing a claim in North Carolina, ensuring that you fully understand the insurance claim process. We want you to be aware of your legal rights and options.
In general, the compensation you could receive for damages in an accident claim against a drunk driver is similar to what you might recover in other car accident claims. The amount of compensation you receive is tied to the specific losses you've sustained. If you have been hit and injured by a drunk driver, you may be entitled to compensation for the following:
In a fatal injury and wrongful death claim, the surviving family members are eligible for compensation for the income and benefits that the deceased would have provided. Family members may also seek damages for loss of companionship and for expenses related to household services. The deceased person's estate should also be entitled to recover costs related to medical bills, funeral and burial expenses, as well as compensation for the pain and suffering experienced by the deceased before passing away.
As we mentioned earlier, you may be able to recover punitive damages in addition to other forms of compensation. If your drunk driving accident attorney in Charlotte, NC provides evidence indicating that the defendant acted in a wanton, willful, or malicious manner, the court may decide to award you and your family punitive damages to penalize the responsible party.
In North Carolina, punitive damages are generally capped at $250,000 or three times the total amount of other damages awarded in your case—whichever amount is greater. However, there is one notable exception to this rule for claims related to drunk driving accidents. If the at-fault driver was impaired at the time of the accident, there is no limit on the punitive damages that can be awarded. It is also noteworthy that if you secure a large verdict against a drunk driver who caused you to be injured, he/she cannot file a bankruptcy and discharge your verdict. Thus, you can pursue collection against the drunk driver's assets for decades after bringing them to trial.
Like the trees and pathways in Freedom Park near Charlotte, evidence serves as a crucial foundation of any drunk driving case. If you're able to do so safely after your accident, capture photographs of the scene, the vehicles involved, and your injuries. This task is easier than it used to be since most of us have smartphones in our pockets.
Try to photograph important details like license plates, vehicle registration, driver's licenses, damage to the vehicles, skid marks, street signs, and more. You can never take too many images at the scene. It's also fine to record a video of the scene and recount what happened. The more you document, the stronger your lawyer's case will be. Be sure to keep track of any personal belongings that were damaged in the incident. This evidence can be integral in illustrating the circumstances and impact of your accident.
In drunk driving cases, our legal team also goes to court in the county where the crash occurred to request Axon/Officer Body Camera footage taken at the crash scene. In most cases, we are able to collect and use this footage. Often their cameras collect footage of the drunk driver slurring their speech, taking field sobriety tests, and showing their level of impairment and carelessness.
Accidents caused by drunk drivers happen when you least expect them. They don't always happen late at night. You could be driving home Saturday morning after eating at The Fig Tree Restaurant in Charlotte, NC and get hit by someone who is intoxicated. The suddenness and severity of these car wrecks cause lasting damage, which you should be compensated for accordingly.
The most common way to seek compensation for personal injury or wrongful death resulting from a drunk driving accident is to file a claim against the intoxicated driver. It's important to note that your accident claim is separate from any criminal charges the driver may face. Moreover, you don't have to wait for a criminal charge or conviction to pursue a claim. However, holding the drunk driver accountable may not be your only legal option. To get the full amount of compensation you deserve, all potentially liable parties should be examined. A skilled drunk driving accident attorney in Charlotte, NC can investigate the situation on your behalf and guide you through your available options.
You might not need to go to court to seek compensation after a drunk driving accident. Typically, the first step is to file a claim with the at-fault driver's insurance company. The insurance provider may try to dispute their liability by arguing that the driver they insured intentionally engaged in reckless behavior by drinking and driving. If this situation arises, your attorney can step in to negotiate on your behalf or, if necessary, file a lawsuit against both the driver and the insurance company.
It may be hard to believe that someone could be under the influence when driving a truck or other large commercial vehicle. Unfortunately, drug and alcohol use among commercial drivers remains a significant issue. Both the driver and their employer can be held liable for accidents caused by impairment. A seasoned attorney can look into the situation to find out if the trucking company neglected to conduct sufficient pre-employment screenings, failed to test drivers for drugs and alcohol, or otherwise acted negligently, leading to the accident.
Dram shop laws hold businesses that sell alcohol accountable for the actions of customers who have been overserved. In North Carolina, these laws also apply to social hosts—private individuals who offer alcohol to their guests—under specific conditions.
Bars, restaurants, and similar establishments can be found liable if they serve alcohol to a customer under the age of 21 in a negligent manner, and that customer subsequently drives drunk and causes an accident. Additionally, businesses are prohibited from serving alcohol to anyone, regardless of age, who appears visibly intoxicated, as this is generally considered negligent service. However, it's important to note that if the overserved customer is 21 or older, the establishment is not held liable in the event of a drunk driving accident.
As a practical matter, you should know that successful host/dram shop cases are rare. We collected a mutli-million dollar settlement on behalf of a grocery store manager who was struck by a drunk driver in Asheville, NC. In that case, the popular restaurant chain served 9 drinks to the drunk driver in just 36 minutes. They then called police on the belligerent drinker, and he fled quickly and caused the collision. The drunk driver's high level of impairment was the key. Drivers must be extremely impaired in these cases, as the host/server has to be aware that the drinker is intoxicated and should not be served. We offer this insight simply to help you plan your legal case. Not every case is a host/dram shop case. However, in extreme impairment cases, steps should be taken immediately to determine where the drunk driver was drinking before the collision occurred.
The laws concerning drunk driving accidents in North Carolina are complex. Determining who is liable, accurately assessing your losses, and pursuing one or more claims for damages can be difficult. Without exceptional legal representation, you might not receive a settlement that reflects what you would collect through a successful trial against the impaired driver who caused your injuries.
However, with Nagle & Associates by your side, you'll have aggressive lawyers, retired State Troopers, experienced medical analysts, and knowledgeable support staff ready to protect and enforce your legal rights. As our client, you will receive individualized attention, empathetic support, and a committed effort to win your case. Most of our cases settle, but we want to settle on your terms - not the discounted terms the insurance company hopes you accept. Call us now for a free consultation by telephone, and we can decide together if you would benefit from our representation. If you need our help, we can begin working for you today.
Bee season is all the buzz in North Carolina.Last week, we told you about carpenter bees, which are one of the most effective pollinators in in the state. Unfortunately, they can also leave behind holes in your deck when they build their nests.However, there’s another pollinator important for crops and wildflowers that usually makes its first appearance during spring: the bumblebee....
Bee season is all the buzz in North Carolina.
Last week, we told you about carpenter bees, which are one of the most effective pollinators in in the state. Unfortunately, they can also leave behind holes in your deck when they build their nests.
However, there’s another pollinator important for crops and wildflowers that usually makes its first appearance during spring: the bumblebee.
Bumblebees, which are sometimes clumsy, usually live in colonies of up to 200 or more, according to NC State Extension.
But how can you tell them apart from carpenter bees? Here’s what to know.
Carpenter bees have “shiny, iridescent, hairless” abdomens that can reflect blue, black and purple colors, while bumblebees aren’t shiny at all and look furry because they’re covered with hair, NC State Extension says.
Bumblebees also behave differently than carpenter bees. Male carpenter bees typically have a zigzag flight pattern and aggressively defend their territory, while female carpenter bees focus on stocking the nest with food.
“They love habitats that are safe and secure,” Chris Hayes, an extension associate of structural pest management at NC State University who specializes educating the pest management industry on critter habits, previously told The Charlotte Observer. “If there were no houses, they would do it in trees. Wood is the perfect environment for them.”
But bumblebees do not hover for long periods and are cautious around humans, NC State Extension says.
It’s unlikely that you’ll get stung by a carpenter bee.
Male bees can’t sting, and “the male carpenter bees are typically the ones you’ll see hovering around the air,” Hayes said.
Female carpenter bees won’t sting unless they’re confined in your hand or become highly agitated.
The same can be said for bumblebees: Female bumblebees can sting if they feel threatened, but they are typically less aggressive than other bee species, according to Charlotte-based A-1 Pest Control.
“Bumblebees contribute significantly to pollination without posing a significant threat to humans, making them valuable and non-threatening contributors to ecosystems,” the company says.
Bumblebees won’t leave holes in your deck or porch like carpenter bees, but if they’re near your home, their presence will be very apparent.
The most obvious indicators that bumblebees are nearby is if you spot them or hear a frequent buzzing sound, according to Terminix. The presence of a nest could also signal that bumblebees are nearby.
“Things to look out for include frequent sightings of large, slow-moving bees around your yard, garden, or near the ground can indicate an established colony nearby,” Terminix says. “Bumblebees produce a distinct buzzing noise while flying. If you hear this sound near potential nesting sites like under decks or within wall spaces, it may signal a nest inside.”
You can use these tips from Western Exterminator Company to keep bumblebees away from your home:
Like carpenter bees, bumblebees are effective pollinators, and NC State Extension discourages killing them if you can avoid them.
But if they’re causing significant damage, the safest way to get rid of carpenter bees is to bring in a pest control professional — but there are methods homeowners can use to get rid of them.
Liquid and dust insecticides that contain pyrethroids, or synthetic insecticides derived from chrysanthemum flowers used for insect control, can be helpful for controlling bees, Hayes previously said — but you shouldn’t use them at the same time, since the dust needs to be dry to work.
Have a question about your community you’d like answered? Or maybe a tip or story idea you’d like to share? The service journalism teams at The News & Observer and The Charlotte Observer want to hear from you.
April 8, 2025 4:49 PM
April 4, 2025 3:38 PM
This story was originally published April 16, 2025 at 4:21 PM.
If you’re new to the Charlotte area, you’ll soon find that strawberry season is kind of a big deal here.Starting in mid-April, fresh, ripe berries will start to flood into the area’s farmers markets, and there are plenty of places you can go to pick them yourself, too, before the season comes to a close in May.Then, you can gorge on all the strawberries you’ve scored, make t...
If you’re new to the Charlotte area, you’ll soon find that strawberry season is kind of a big deal here.
Starting in mid-April, fresh, ripe berries will start to flood into the area’s farmers markets, and there are plenty of places you can go to pick them yourself, too, before the season comes to a close in May.
Then, you can gorge on all the strawberries you’ve scored, make them into strawberry shortcake or jam, or even make one of my favorite spring recipes, chef Greg Collier’s Grilled Gus with Toasted Almond Vin and Strawberries.
Pro tips: Weekends are often pretty crowded in the Charlotte area’s strawberry fields, so if you can go on a weekday, you won’t be fighting the crowds. You’ll also want to check social media for your farm of choice before you go, as conditions are often subject to change.
Here are farms where you can pick your own strawberries near Charlotte.
Location: Farm, 1650 Filbert Hwy, York, SC 29745
Location: Rock Hill farm stand (next to Dollar General), 1662 Ebenezer Rd, Rock Hill, SC
Location: Lake Wylie farm stand (next to Bagel Boat), 4090 Charlotte Hwy, Lake Wylie, SC
What to know: Bush & Vine’s pick-your-own strawberry patch opens mid-April and typically closes in mid-May, but is subject to change depending on the weather and other factors. You can pick as soon as Saturday, April 19.
It will be open on Saturdays from 8 a.m.-3 p.m., and they suggest you come early. Buckets are provided. (Follow the farm on Twitter or Facebook or Instagram to receive updates.)
Cost: $4.25/pound
Location: 1261 Oakridge Farm Hwy, Mooresville, NC 28115
What to know: Carrigan Farms offers strawberry picking across 5 acres with no reservations needed. The farm is open for strawberry picking starting April 24, and owners anticipate the season lasting through the end of May. (Check the website before you go for availability.)
Cost: $22 per 4 quart basket and $8 per 1 quart container. Pre-picked quarts are $24.
Pro tip: The farm also has fresh asparagus and heirloom leaf lettuce available through early May.
Location: 445 W Rebound Rd, Lancaster, SC 29720
What to know: Hall Family Farms has opened the strawberry fields for picking this year.
Hours are Tuesday-Sunday, 9 a.m.-6 p.m. with varying times for ticketed activities and food, especially on school holidays and during school field trips. (The farm recommends you stay tuned to its Facebook and Instagram accounts for updates, or call ahead at (704) 562-4021 to hear its daily update before you head out to the farm.)
Cost: U-pick and pre-picked strawberries are $3.99/pound.
Location: 8525 Van Wyck Rd, Lancaster, SC 29720
What to know: The Ivy Place’s strawberry season has begun and will last until June. (Its website includes updates on picking availability and conditions.)
Cost: $3.89/pound. Pre-picked strawberries are also available for $8/quart, $12/half gallon and $24/gallon.
[HIDDEN GEMS: 5 best underrated places to hike within 90 minutes of Charlotte.]
Location: 906 Dallas Stanley Hwy, Dallas, NC 28034
What to know: Strawberry picking is available from mid-to-late April through June at the Lake Norman area farm that grows its berries the old-fashioned way — on straw. The playground is free to visit, as well. This year, you can start picking Saturday, April 19.
Cost: Pre-picked berries are $10/1/2 gallon, and this year’s u-pick prices are $9 for 1/2 gallon or $16/gallon.
Location: 10390 Caldwell Road, Mount Ulla, NC 28125
What to know: Patterson Farm’s strawberry picking fields, northeast of the Lake Norman area, have a growing season that typically runs from April to mid-June. This year, it hasn’t announced an opening date yet.
Cost: Last year’s pricing was set at $1 online or $3 per person admission at the gate, plus $9 per basket. For access to the barn and playground, as well, tickets are $13 online or $15 per person at the gate on the weekend (including a cow train and wagon ride) and weekdays are $10 online or $12 per person at the gate. Purchase tickets online.
Pre-picked strawberries can also be purchased at the farm for $6 per quart, $20 per bucket or $20 for a 4 quart basket.
Location: 835 Springfield Parkway, Fort Mill, SC 29715
What to know: Springs Farms’ strawberry fields will be open starting Friday and Saturday from 10 a.m.-6 p.m. They’ll remain open through the end of May, and no reservations are needed. Its indoor market stocked with local and handmade items, ice cream and slushies will also be open. (Follow its Facebook and Instagram for updates.)
Cost: Pricing has not yet been released. Last year’s pricing was set at $4.25 per pound, with a fully picked gallon container estimated at $25.50 — and its pick-your-own stand only takes credit cards.
Charlotte, NC (April 16, 2025) – Emergency responders rushed to the scene of a crash with injuries reported at the intersection of Shopton Rd W and Westinghouse Blvd early Wednesday morning. The incident occurred in the Steele Creek area at approximately 8:32 a.m., prompting a swift response from Charlotte Fire and Rescue and other emergency personnel.Medics and fire crews worked to assist those suffering from injuries after the collision, which involved at least two vehicles. The intersection, a busy commuter route near ...
Charlotte, NC (April 16, 2025) – Emergency responders rushed to the scene of a crash with injuries reported at the intersection of Shopton Rd W and Westinghouse Blvd early Wednesday morning. The incident occurred in the Steele Creek area at approximately 8:32 a.m., prompting a swift response from Charlotte Fire and Rescue and other emergency personnel.
Medics and fire crews worked to assist those suffering from injuries after the collision, which involved at least two vehicles. The intersection, a busy commuter route near commercial and industrial zones, experienced delays as responders secured the scene and provided medical attention. The nature and extent of the injuries sustained were not publicly detailed at the time of the report.
Authorities confirmed that the crash resulted in temporary traffic disruptions while responders cleared the roadway and gathered preliminary information. The exact cause of the accident remains under investigation.
Our thoughts are with those affected by this accident.
North Carolina is home to numerous high-traffic corridors, and intersections like Shopton Rd W and Westinghouse Blvd can be particularly vulnerable due to heavy industrial traffic and commuter flow. Accidents in areas such as Steele Creek often involve vehicles maneuvering through mixed-use zones where commercial trucks, passenger vehicles, and turning traffic intersect. These dynamics increase the risk of collisions, especially during peak travel times.
According to recent data from the North Carolina Department of Transportation, injury accidents have steadily risen in Mecklenburg County over the past few years. While Charlotte continues to grow, so too does the complexity of its road networks. High-speed limits, rapid urban development, and occasional infrastructure limitations are key factors contributing to regional crash trends.
In response, local officials have emphasized the importance of awareness and defensive driving, especially at signalized intersections. Motorists are urged to approach intersections with caution, anticipate sudden stops, and remain vigilant for lane changes and cross traffic. Drivers navigating through Steele Creek and surrounding communities should also stay alert for large vehicles entering or exiting industrial facilities.
If you’ve been injured in a similar incident in North Carolina, it’s important to understand your rights. Navigating the aftermath of a crash involves medical care, insurance claims, and potentially legal steps, especially if another party’s negligence is suspected. Seeking guidance and staying informed about local traffic patterns can help reduce the risk of future collisions.
For more information or to receive help after an accident, contact Local Accident Reports.
What makes an animal a pet?That they come when called? The way they curl up and rest in your lap while you watch TV? Or that they’ll ride in the car with you — for a morning coffee or on trips to Hilton Head Island?Mary Schroeder had this and more with what she considered to be her pets — a flock of 62 chickens.They were kept in a backyard coop at her Waxhaw home, and Schroeder nurtured a deep bond with the birds. The Schroeders don’t eat their chickens but occasionally use their eggs to make omel...
What makes an animal a pet?
That they come when called? The way they curl up and rest in your lap while you watch TV? Or that they’ll ride in the car with you — for a morning coffee or on trips to Hilton Head Island?
Mary Schroeder had this and more with what she considered to be her pets — a flock of 62 chickens.
They were kept in a backyard coop at her Waxhaw home, and Schroeder nurtured a deep bond with the birds. The Schroeders don’t eat their chickens but occasionally use their eggs to make omelets.
Each chicken had a name — several were christened by her young daughter, dubbed after family members or the birds’ unique flair.
The coop became a place of refuge. Schroeder would spend at least an hour with the chickens each day. Like any pet, Schroeder said, she could hold them in her low moments, listen to their soft purr and find herself at ease.
“I always said if I was having a bad day or a stressful day, I didn’t spend enough time out in the coop,” she said.
But ask the Oak Grove Farm Homeowners Association about Schroeder’s pets, and they say the birds were anything but.
They were poultry, the HOA alleged, according to court documents. And poultry on Schroeder’s property was a direct violation of the community’s legally binding rules. Lawyers for Oak Grove Farm Homeowners Association declined to comment for this story.
Neighbors were starting to complain, the HOA said. The chickens had to go, or the HOA would impose fines, court documents revealed. But Schroeder and her husband, Craig, refused — resulting in a whopping $31,500 in fines.
Schroeder and her husband sued their HOA and kickstarted a five-year legal battle that will soon be put to rest by the highest court in the state. On Tuesday, the North Carolina Supreme Court will hear arguments from both parties and decide once and for all — can these chickens be considered pets? Or are they just poultry?
The power of HOAs over homeowners has been a tense conversation across North Carolina. Homeowners can find themselves in legal trouble with their HOA over trees or types of windows. A 2023 Observer investigation highlighted how state rules make it easy for HOAs to foreclose on homeowners for the smallest of unpaid fines.
This legislative session, two bills aim to limit HOAs’ power and remove the possibility for homeowners to be fined for things such as parking their cars on the street, offering tutoring classes in their homes and more.
This case is bigger than her situation, Schroeder said.
“(This is) for all the people that want free use of land,” she said. “Maybe people who live in an HOA that are being harassed or that are having issues. Or people who just want to have backyard chickens.”
The first chicken Schroeder ever loved was named Pecker.
She named him after the way “he pecked all around the yard and on the ground.”
Her father, a mechanic in Fayette County, Ohio, worked on equipment for farmers. One day, through some sort of barter, Schroeder’s father came home with the bird. Little did he know he was igniting a love for chickens in his little girl.
Schroeder loved Pecker. She taught the bird tricks and played with him for hours. It was from that moment she knew she was destined to have chickens in her life.
When she and her husband began looking for a house in Union County in 2016, acreage was at the top of their wish list. They needed enough land to build a coop suitable for her chickens, a barn for horses and enough land for their dogs and cats to roam.
The Oak Grove Farm, a gated community in Waxhaw, provided just that. They toured three homes in the subdivision before deciding on a house with 17 acres, she said.
“This was our dream home. This was what we wanted,” Schroeder said. “We fell in love with the home. We fell in love with the neighborhood. We fell in love with the land.”
With each house they toured, they asked their Realtor to ensure with the HOA that chickens would be allowed.
And when the Schroeders first moved in, they were, in practice if not officially. The community’s legally binding rules state that other than horses, “No other animals, livestock, or poultry of any kind, shall be raised, bred, or kept on any lot except that dogs, cats, or other household pets may be kept provided that they (including horses) are not kept, bred, or maintained for any commercial purpose.”
But court records reveal that the HOA was lenient on this particular rule at the time and knew of other households that had chickens. But the numbers were small and complaints were nonexistent.
The Schroeders followed suit and started out with five hens — Laverne, Lizzie, Marie, Evie and Lucy. They were named after the middle names of the couple’s mothers and grandmothers.
The HOA was fine with the few hens initially, according to court documents. But problems arose over the next two years when their flock increased more than 12 fold.
Complaints from neighbors about the smell and the sheer number of chickens pushed the HOA to take a stance, according to court documents. The poultry had to go.
The HOA sent a letter to all residents instructing them that chickens had to be removed. If not, fines would be imposed.
Everyone complied except the Schroeders.
Her chickens had never been a problem, Schroeder said. No one ever complained to her about a smell. And a neighbor once told her that if she never talked about the birds, she would’ve never known they were there.
Getting rid of them was out of the question.
“These are my pets. Why would I get rid of my pets?” she said. “Because you’re telling me that I could have them and then tell me I can’t have them. It didn’t make any sense to me.”
Schroeder’s refusal had consequences. The HOA began charging the couple $100 a day until the birds were removed.
Once the fees hit $31,500, Schroeder found a new home for more than half of her chickens and took the rest to stay with her friend in Lake Norman. She’d make the hour and a half drive every week to spend time with them.
The fines were unfair, Schroeder said. So she and her husband decided to sue.
The first case in Union County Superior Court was a jury trial.
The HOA sought to prove not only that the Schroeders’ chickens weren’t pets, but that the birds were being used for commercial use — another violation of the community’s rules.
Schroeder made a Facebook post in 2019 saying that she sold farm eggs and was looking for places to donate her extras.
After a two-day trial, the 12-person jury decided that Schroeder’s beloved chickens were not pets. The court found that the couple was indeed in violation of the HOA’s legally binding rules and therefore was required to pay the fines.
The Schroeders appealed to the North Carolina Court of Appeals.
Judges there reversed the lower court’s decision, saying the HOA failed to bring a “scintilla” of evidence that Schroeder’s chickens were not household pets or were keeping the birds for commercial use.
In May 2024, the HOA appealed to the state Supreme Court. It will be heard on April 22.
Over the course of five years, the Schroeders have spent nearly $50,000 in legal fees. And although they moved out of the neighborhood, the HOA placed a lien on their home forcing them to pay the $31,500 fine.
The legal battle was only one part of the stress, Schroeder said. Outside of the courtroom, this dispute had driven a wedge between her family and the rest of the neighborhood.
Their daughter would get teased by kids on the bus, people would make comments to them as they walked their dogs and Schroeder said she was even confronted by a neighbor at a Wesley Chapel Harris Teeter.
“Why are you causing all this trouble? You’re such a B. Why can’t you just let people be happy?” she recalled the man yelling at her.
Schroeder was relying on anxiety and anti-depression medications to get through the day. Staying in Oak Grove Farm was becoming too much.
So in 2022, she and her husband decided to sell their home and head to the next town over — Monroe.
Their new backyard has become their own personal farm.
On their 33 acres, the clucks and crows from their flock of 60 chickens and two turkeys is constant. From her barrel seat by the coop Schroeder watches her cows and horses roam on one side of the yard. And she keeps a watchful eye on her donkey, sheep and goats on the other. Once her ducks and geese get tired of the pond, they make their way to land to mingle with their bird friends.
This is the life, Schroeder said. Living in a home that she built and on land that she owns without the watchful eye of an HOA. Here, she can do what she wants without asking for anyone’s permission.
Schroeder said she never expected her case to reach the state Supreme Court. But she hopes her story will act as a cautionary tale about the overbearing power of homeowner associations in the state.
“I would never live in an HOA again,” she said. “It could be the most perfect environment in the world, and if it had an HOA … no.”
This story was originally published April 17, 2025 at 5:00 AM.
BL
The Charlotte Observer
Briah Lumpkins is the emerging news reporter for the Charlotte Observer. In this role, she finds important and impactful enterprise stories impacting the Charlotte-metro region. Most previously, Briah spent time in Houston, Texas covering underrepresented suburban communities at the Houston Landing. Prior to that, she spent a year at the Charleston Post and Courier for an investigative reporting fellowship through FRONTLINE PBS. When she’s not at work you can find her binge reading on her kindle or at the movie theater watching the latest premieres.
Charlotte, NC (April 16, 2025) – Emergency responders were quick to the scene, providing care to the injured victims following a traffic collision that occurred early Wednesday afternoon in Charlotte’s Freedom neighborhood. The crash was reported around 12:52 p.m. in the 1200 block of Rhyne Rd, a residential route that connects local traffic to larger roadways in the western part of the city.Charlotte Fire and Rescue units responded promptly to the incident, working to assist those hurt in the accident. Specific det...
Charlotte, NC (April 16, 2025) – Emergency responders were quick to the scene, providing care to the injured victims following a traffic collision that occurred early Wednesday afternoon in Charlotte’s Freedom neighborhood. The crash was reported around 12:52 p.m. in the 1200 block of Rhyne Rd, a residential route that connects local traffic to larger roadways in the western part of the city.
Charlotte Fire and Rescue units responded promptly to the incident, working to assist those hurt in the accident. Specific details regarding the number of vehicles involved or the extent of injuries have not been disclosed as of this report.
The section of Rhyne Rd near the scene experienced brief travel delays as responders treated the injured and ensured the area was safe. Authorities have initiated an investigation to determine the cause of the crash, which remains undetermined at this time.
Our thoughts are with all individuals impacted by this accident.
The Freedom area of Charlotte, where Rhyne Rd is located, has become increasingly traveled due to nearby development and access to major corridors like Freedom Dr and I-85. While Rhyne Rd serves primarily residential traffic, it often sees overflow from busier main roads—raising the risk of local crashes, especially during midday hours when deliveries and short trips peak.
Injury accidents in areas like Freedom can be especially concerning due to limited street lighting, frequent intersections, and occasional blind curves common to older neighborhood infrastructure. While the speed limits may be lower than in commercial areas, the risk of injury remains high when drivers are distracted or traveling too fast for road conditions.
The Charlotte Department of Transportation has prioritized traffic safety in residential sectors by promoting safe-driving initiatives and enhancing visibility through improved signage and road maintenance. Still, the majority of injury collisions stem from driver behavior—such as ignoring stop signs, looking at phones, or failing to account for nearby pedestrians or cyclists.
With the investigation ongoing into the Rhyne Rd accident, residents are encouraged to stay vigilant while driving through residential neighborhoods. Ensuring full stops at intersections, limiting distractions, and maintaining appropriate speed can help reduce the number of injury crashes in Charlotte’s western districts.
If you or someone you know has been injured in a crash, reach out to Local Accident Reports for assistance.